This post contains affiliate links to the products that I use and trust. This means that I might receive a small commission (at no extra cost to you) if you make a purchase using any of my links below. See full disclosure here.
Cape May isn’t just about beach towels and taffy. Sure, the shoreline is stunning, but if you’re up for something off the tourist trail, this gem of a town is brimming with surprises. From secret gardens to tucked-away speakeasies, it’s got a quiet magic you only find when you wander a little further. Whether you’re visiting for the first time or coming back for round ten, let’s dig into the under-the-radar spots that make Cape May unforgettable.
Let’s Dig In.
Tabel of Contents
- 1 1. The Sunken Ship of Sunset Beach
- 2 2. The Willow Creek Winery: Wine & Alpacas?
- 3 3. WWII Lookout Tower: History with a View
- 4 4. Cape May Bird Observatory: Feathered Finds
- 5 5. The Spirit of Cape May: Cruise Under the Stars
- 6 6. Beach Plum Farm: A Real-Life Fairytale
- 7 7. Tiki Ten35: Speakeasy Vibes in the Back of a Liquor Store
1. The Sunken Ship of Sunset Beach
You’ve heard of Sunset Beach for its epic golden hour views, but did you know there’s a real shipwreck just offshore? The SS Atlantus, a concrete ship built during World War I, is partially visible from the beach. It’s eerie, fascinating, and makes for a killer photo op.
Pro Tip: Bring binoculars and a beach chair. It’s also a great place to hunt for Cape May “diamonds”—quartz crystals that wash up along the shore.
2. The Willow Creek Winery: Wine & Alpacas?
Tucked just off the main road lies Willow Creek Winery, where you can sip local blends surrounded by gardens, and vines. They have events May throug September. Sangria Sundays are happening now.
They also offer fire pit evenings, tasting flights, and charcuterie. It’s one of Cape May’s best-kept vineyard secrets.
3. WWII Lookout Tower: History with a View
A hidden slice of history, the World War II Lookout Tower (Fire Control Tower No. 23) gives you insight into Cape May’s lesser-known role during wartime. Climb to the top for panoramic views and check out the honor plaques inside.
Pro Tip: It’s rarely crowded and incredibly peaceful at sunset.
4. Cape May Bird Observatory: Feathered Finds
Even if you’re not a hardcore birder, the Cape May Bird Observatory is worth a visit. During migration season (especially fall), the sky comes alive with hawks, monarchs, and songbirds.
Pro Tip: Visit the Northwood Center for trail maps and the best viewing times. Early mornings = birdwatching gold.
Birdwatching: the original reality show.
5. The Spirit of Cape May: Cruise Under the Stars
For a night to remember, climb aboard The Spirit of Cape May, a 110-foot yacht offering scenic sunset dinner cruises and private charters. With cushioned seating, two bars, a climate-controlled cabin, and an open-air dance floor under the stars, it’s perfect for parties, reunions, or just a relaxing evening on the water. The vibe is part laid-back luxury, part celebration.
Pro Tip: Have a group of 50 or more? A private charter might be the perfect (and surprisingly doable) way to celebrate something special.
6. Beach Plum Farm: A Real-Life Fairytale
Five minutes outside of town, Beach Plum Farm is Cape May’s ultimate pastoral escape. Wander through herb gardens, shop fresh produce, or dine alfresco under the trees. It’s like
They also offer overnight stays in adorable cottages if you want that cozy farm-life fantasy.
Pro Tip: Visit during spring or fall for the best colors and fewer crowds.
7. Tiki Ten35: Speakeasy Vibes in the Back of a Liquor Store
Ready for a cocktail adventure? Find Tiki Ten35, light hearted bar menu featuring food from the on-site restaurant SeaSalt and serves up frosty cocktails day and night on Beach Ave in the Ocean Club Hotel. It’s got tiki bar pool vibe withcocktails, andmoody lighting.
Pro Tip: Follow their socials for special event nights and off-menu drinks.
Hidden tiki treasure.
Explore the Quiet Corners of Cape May
Cape May rewards the curious traveler. Sure, you can stick to the beach and have a great time, but if you dig a little deeper, the town opens up in unexpected, magical ways. From tiki bars and sunken ships to vineyards and birdwatching, this little beach town has layers you won’t find in a brochure.
Looking for even more to explore? Hop on the ferry and discover the charm of Delaware’s beaches — just a short ride away. For tips, check out my blog The Ultimate Guide to Beach Day Adventures.
Ready to experience Cape May beyond the boardwalk? Drop your favorite hidden spots in the comments or tag your finds with #CapeMaySecrets.
Stay curious, stay hungry, and keep exploring!
–Beth
