Cape May isn’t just about beach towels and taffy. Sure, the shoreline is stunning, but if you’re up for something off the tourist trail, this gem of a town is brimming with surprises. From secret gardens to tucked-away speakeasies, it’s got a quiet magic you only find when you wander a little further. Whether you’re visiting for the first time or coming back for round ten, let’s dig into the under-the-radar spots that make Cape May unforgettable.

Let’s Dig In.

• Facebook
• Instagram
• Pinterest

_Disclaimer

_{^{This post contains affiliate links to the products that I use and trust. This means that I might receive a small commission (at no extra cost to you) if you make a purchase using any of my links below. See full disclosure here}}

1. The Sunken Ship of Sunset Beach

You’ve heard of Sunset Beach for its epic golden hour views, but did you know there’s a real shipwreck just offshore? The SS Atlantus, a concrete ship built during World War I, is partially visible from the beach. It’s eerie, fascinating, and makes for a killer photo op.

Pro Tip: Bring binoculars and a beach chair. It’s also a great place to hunt for Cape May “diamonds”—quartz crystals that wash up along the shore.

2. The Willow Creek Winery: Wine & Alpacas?

Tucked just off the main road lies Willow Creek Winery, where you can sip local blends surrounded by gardens, and vines. They have events May throug September. Sangria Sundays are happening now.

They also offer fire pit evenings, tasting flights, and charcuterie. It’s one of Cape May’s best-kept vineyard secrets.

3. WWII Lookout Tower: History with a View

A hidden slice of history, the World War II Lookout Tower (Fire Control Tower No. 23) gives you insight into Cape May’s lesser-known role during wartime. Climb to the top for panoramic views and check out the honor plaques inside.

Pro Tip: It’s rarely crowded and incredibly peaceful at sunset.

4. Cape May Bird Observatory: Feathered Finds

Even if you’re not a hardcore birder, the Cape May Bird Observatory is worth a visit. During migration season (especially fall), the sky comes alive with hawks, monarchs, and songbirds.

Pro Tip: Visit the Northwood Center for trail maps and the best viewing times. Early mornings = birdwatching gold.

Birdwatching: the original reality show.

5. The Spirit of Cape May: Cruise Under the Stars

For a night to remember, climb aboard The Spirit of Cape May, a 110-foot yacht offering scenic sunset dinner cruises and private charters. With cushioned seating, two bars, a climate-controlled cabin, and an open-air dance floor under the stars, it’s perfect for parties, reunions, or just a relaxing evening on the water. The vibe is part laid-back luxury, part celebration.

Pro Tip: Have a group of 50 or more? A private charter might be the perfect (and surprisingly doable) way to celebrate something special.

6. Beach Plum Farm: A Real-Life Fairytale

Five minutes outside of town, Beach Plum Farm is Cape May’s ultimate pastoral escape. Wander through herb gardens, shop fresh produce, or dine alfresco under the trees. It’s like 

They also offer overnight stays in adorable cottages if you want that cozy farm-life fantasy.

Pro Tip: Visit during spring or fall for the best colors and fewer crowds.

7. Tiki Ten35: Speakeasy Vibes in the Back of a Liquor Store

Ready for a cocktail adventure? Find Tiki Ten35,  light hearted bar menu featuring food from the on-site restaurant SeaSalt and serves up frosty cocktails day and night on Beach Ave in the Ocean Club Hotel. It’s got tiki bar pool vibe withcocktails,  andmoody lighting.

Pro Tip: Follow their socials for special event nights and off-menu drinks.

Hidden tiki treasure.

 Explore the Quiet Corners of Cape May

Cape May rewards the curious traveler. Sure, you can stick to the beach and have a great time, but if you dig a little deeper, the town opens up in unexpected, magical ways. From tiki bars and sunken ships to vineyards and birdwatching, this little beach town has layers you won’t find in a brochure.

Looking for even more to explore? Hop on the ferry and discover the charm of Delaware’s beaches — just a short ride away. For tips, check out my blog The Ultimate Guide to Beach Day Adventures.

Ready to experience Cape May beyond the boardwalk? Drop your favorite hidden spots in the comments or tag your finds with #CapeMaySecrets.

Stay curious, stay hungry, and keep exploring!

–Beth

Looking for a dreamy getaway that feels like you stepped into a storybook? You’re in the right place. The Cape May Historic District is dripping with vintage charm, full of colorful Victorian homes, and has just enough modern flair to keep things fun. Whether you’re a history buff, design lover, or just want a photo-worthy day trip, this charming neighborhood delivers.

Let’s Dig In.

• Facebook
• Instagram
• Pinterest

_Disclaimer

_{^{This post contains affiliate links to the products that I use and trust. This means that I might receive a small commission (at no extra cost to you) if you make a purchase using any of my links below. See full disclosure here}}

What Makes Cape May’s Historic District So Special?

The Cape May Historic District is no ordinary beach town stroll. It’s a National Historic Landmark, featuring more than 600 preserved Victorian buildings, each telling a story in gingerbread trim and pastel hues. And the best part? You don’t need a museum ticket—just comfy shoes, a curious eye, and maybe a scone or two along the way. Don’t forget your camera or iPhone, you will want to take pictures.

Must-See Highlights:

• Columbia Avenue & Hughes Street: Iconic Victorian homes that look like dollhouses come to life.
• Cape May Welcome Center: Grab a free self-guided walking tour map here.
• Carriage rides (seasonal): Take a tour in style and get all the juicy historical tidbits with zero footwork.

Why You’ll Love Walking Around Cape May Historic District

Let’s be real—sometimes, historic towns can feel a little… dusty. Not Cape May. The streets are walkable, the homes are radiant, and the vibe is cozy-meets-classy. Every block gives you something to admire, from ornate weathervanes to lush gardens straight out of a magazine spread.

Pro Tip: Visit in the late afternoon for golden-hour lighting and fewer crowds. Bonus: It makes your photos pop!

Shop Like a Local: Washington Street Mall

Once you’ve had your fill of architectural eye candy, head to the Washington Street Mall—a charming pedestrian-only stretch packed with boutiques, cafes, and gift shops. It’s the kind of place where window shopping turns into actual shopping before you even realize it.

Don’t Miss:

• The Whale’s Tale: Whimsical finds and local art.
• Love the Cook: Gourmet gifts, quirky kitchenware, and samples galore.
• Across the Way: Unique gifts and accents for the home

Pro Tip: There are plenty of shaded benches for a mid-shopping ice cream break.

Dinner at the Vintage

After giving your feet—and your wallet—a proper workout, unwind at Vintage, nestled within the historic Emlen Physick Estate. Part of Cape May’s vibrant M.A.C. (Music. Art. Culture) scene, Vintage offers a cozy spot to indulge. Stop by for a laid-back brunch and treat yourself to the decadent Cheesecake Waffle, or savor a refined dinner with classic dishes like Cacio e Pepe

And if you’re into ghost stories? Stick around for their evening haunted tours. The tea is hot—and so are the paranormal rumors.

Pro Tip: Book your table ahead of time, especially in the summer season.

Step Inside the Emlen Physick Estate

Want to really dig into Cape May’s backstory? Take a tour of the Emlen Physick Estate, a gorgeously restored Victorian mansion filled with original furnishings and juicy tales about the Physick family (spoiler: they were Cape May royalty). It’s the only Victorian house museum in town and totally worth the hour.

Pro Tip: The combo ticket includes a trolley tour through the historic district—hello, double win.

Picture-Perfect Moments: Photo Ops You Don’t Want to Miss

Cape May’s Historic District is an Instagram dream. Whether you’re all about decorative fencing or color-blocked porches, here’s where to snap some keeper shots:

• Gas-lit street lamps at dusk
• Wrought-iron gates with ivy
• A pink or lavender house with lace curtains
• Horse-drawn carriage turning the corner

Photo Tip: Bring a wide-angle lens if possible, and take your time—this place was made for slow exploring.

One Perfect Day in Cape May’s Historic District

In just one day, you’ll wander back in time, admiring  Victorian architecture, and score some sweet finds along the way. The Cape May Historic District isn’t just a pretty face—it’s got soul, sass, and stories waiting to be uncovered.

So lace up your comfiest shoes, charge that phone, and dive into one of the East Coast’s most photogenic (and fascinating) neighborhoods.

Pro Tip: Book your tours early and bring cash—some of the best local gems don’t take cards.

Have a favorite house or hidden gem in Cape May’s historic core? Share your must-sees in the comments or tag your adventures with #CapeMayCharm.

Stay curious, stay hungry, and keep exploring!

–Beth

Set Sail for Charm: Your Cape May Day Trip Starts with a Ferry Adventure

If you’ve ever thought, “Wouldn’t it be fun to hop on a ferry, cross a sparkling bay, and end up in a Victorian beach town full of charm?” — you’re in luck. The Cape May-Lewes Ferry makes that dreamy day trip a reality. Whether you’re coming from Dewey Beach or Fenwick Island, it’s a smooth ride from Delaware to Cape May, New Jersey. The ferry isn’t just transportation — it’s part of the adventure.

Want breezy decks, dolphin sightings, seaside eats, and strolls through a town so pretty it looks like it was designed by Pinterest? You’re in the right place. Let’s Dig In.

• Facebook
• Instagram
• Pinterest

_Disclaimer

_{^{This post contains affiliate links to the products that I use and trust. This means that I might receive a small commission (at no extra cost to you) if you make a purchase using any of my links below. See full disclosure here}}

Why Take the Ferry? Because the Journey Is the Destination

Taking the ferry is the easiest and most scenic way to travel from Delaware beaches to Cape May. Here’s why:

• No highway stress — skip the traffic
• Breathtaking views of Delaware Bay
• Dog-friendly decks (yes, pups can ride too!)
• Indoor lounges and outdoor seating for all moods
• Snacks, drinks, and a breezy bar to kickstart vacation mode

Pro Tip: Book your ticket in advance at CMLF.com to guarantee your preferred sailing time, especially during weekends and summer months.

What to Expect Onboard: Views, Vibes & Vino

Once you’re on board, it’s time to relax. Head to the top deck for panoramic water views. You might spot dolphins or pelicans gliding by. Inside, there’s air-conditioned seating, a snack bar, and even local beer on tap.

Traveling with kids? There’s a small play area and plenty of space to explore. Bringing your dog? Just keep them leashed and let them enjoy the salty wind.

The ride lasts about 85 minutes, giving you just enough time to unwind before your next adventure.

Arriving in Cape May: Pastel Homes & Porch Swings Await

Once you dock in Cape May, you’re stepping into one of the most picturesque seaside towns on the East Coast. Think:

• Charming Victorian homes with pastel paint and wraparound porches
• Bike-friendly streets for cruising past beach cottages
• Lively Washington Street Mall for shopping and snacks
• Beaches that stretch forever, perfect for lounging or walking

Must-Eat Spots for Your Cape May Day

You worked up an appetite ferry-hopping, right? Here are a few can’t-miss options:

• The Lobster House: Legendary waterfront seafood with boat views
• The Mad Batter: Brunch goals with creative cocktails
• Cape May Fish Market: For quick and delicious fresh catches

Need something sweet? Grab a cone from Kohr Bros. Frozen Custard and enjoy it on the promenade.

Beach or Lighthouse? Both, Please.

Before heading back, make time for Cape May Lighthouse. Climb the 199 steps for panoramic views of the coastline and the Delaware Bay—yes, the same bay you just crossed!

Not feeling the climb? Relax on Higbee Beach nearby. It’s a hidden gem with fewer crowds and stunning sunsets.

Ride Back with Memories & Salt Air in Your Hair

Head back to the ferry terminal with enough time to catch your return sailing. Evening ferries are especially magical with the golden hour light dancing on the waves.

Pro Tip: Sit on the west-facing side for the best sunset views.

This isn’t just a travel day—it’s a full-circle seaside story.

Turn a Simple Day Trip into a Mini-Vacation

The Cape May-Lewes Ferry doesn’t just connect Delaware and New Jersey. It connects moments: quiet beach mornings in Dewey, salty breezes on deck, pastel homes in Cape May, and laughter echoing from dinner on the shore.

So what are you waiting for? Whether you’re planning a quick escape or an all-day adventure, this ferry ride is your gateway to one of the most charming coastal towns around. If you are wanting to explore more of Cape May read the blog Discover the Cape May Historic District

Leave a comment if you’ve taken the ferry or have a favorite Cape May spot to share. And don’t forget to tag me in your ferry-side selfies!

Stay curious, stay hungry, and keep exploring!

–Beth