Restaurants in Erie, PA You’ll Love 

Welcome to one of my favourite foodie stops: Erie, Pennsylvania. If you’re looking to explore the best restaurants in Erie, PA, you’ve hit the right blog. I’ve travelled the United States of America, tasted everything from the New England states’ clam chowder to Oregon’s marionberries, and I’ll tell you—Erie has serious flavor. Whether you’re after lakeside seafood or a fun college-bar atmosphere, I’ve got six terrific spots for you. Erie is not known for many vegetarian spots, but you’re in luck if you are a seafood lover. Let’s Dig In!

• Facebook
• Instagram
• Pinterest

_Disclaimer

_{^{This post contains affiliate links to the products that I use and trust. This means that I might receive a small commission (at no extra cost to you) if you make a purchase using any of my links below. See full disclosure here}}

Why these restaurants in Erie, PA, matter to you

If you’ve ever wondered where in Erie you can get amazing food with local flavor, here’s the quick answer. These picks deliver:

• Scenic waterfront dining: Think lake breeze, sunset views, and waterfront patios.
  
• Local-inspired menus: From Lake Erie walleye to regional craft beer, the menus reflect place.
  
• Easygoing but memorable atmosphere: Whether you’re on a date, grabbing dinner with friends, or hunting a post-game burger, there’s something here.
  
• Something for the college town vibe: Yes, even the bar scene is part of this blog.
  

So while I’ve just mentioned what’s good, let me break down each location and show you exactly what you can experience (and what to ask for).

1. Big view, big flavor: Two45 Waterfront Grille (Bayfront)

Let’s start strong. At Two45 Waterfront Grille, you’ll dine inside the sleek lobby of the Sheraton Erie Bayfront Hotel, overlooking the water. It’s upscale yet relaxed. The menu? Traditional American with a coastal twist: think macadamia-nut crusted grouper, wild rice, and walleye. 

What I loved: Sitting by the floor-to-ceiling windows as the sun dipped behind the bay. Hearing the soft clink of glasses, the glow from the patio lights. You’ll feel that you’re treating yourself.

Pro tip for you: Make a reservation and ask for a “bay view” table — it’s worth the extra step. And if you go for brunch? Check times early (weekends often).

2. Elevated steak & seafood: Firebirds Wood Fired Grill

For a hearty meal in a casual-elegant setting, head to Firebirds Wood Fired Grill at the Millcreek Mall complex. They specialize in wood-fired steaks, fresh seafood, and scratch kitchen fare.

What I loved: The warm glow of the fire pit, the sound of meat sizzling, the comfort of a big steak with friends who ask no questions when you order cake for dessert.

Pro tip: Try to go early in the week or for lunch—less crowded and you’ll get service that feels relaxed rather than rushed. And if you want lighter fare, ask about salads or seafood options—it’s not just “meat and potatoes”.

3. Chill waterfront dining: Shoreline Bar & Grille

If you’re after relaxed bayfront charm, check out Shoreline Bar & Grille in the Courtyard Erie Bayfront hotel. Their tagline says it all: fresh regional cuisine and gorgeous waterside views. 

What I loved: The breeze off the bay, the seafood plate that hits local notes (hello Lake Erie walleye), and the vibe of sitting outside at golden hour.

Pro tip: Grab patio seating if the weather’s nice. And if you have a group, you’ll find it’s casual enough to bring friends, smart enough for a date.

4. Nautical fun for seafood lovers: Smuggler’s Wharf

For a more playful vibe, try Smuggler’s Wharf (3 State Street, Erie). Nautical theme, lots of variety on the menu (seafood and they have veg burgers), outdoor seating overlooking the bay. 

What I loved: Sitting outside by the water, shrimp dipped in coconut, lemonade in your glass, breeze in your hair. A little less formal, a lot more fun.
Pro tip: If you want the deck view, ask specifically for “waterfront deck” seating. And don’t skip dessert—locals rave.

5. Historic brew-pub atmosphere: The Brewerie at Union Station

When you want food and a local craft-beer experience, head to The Brewerie at Union Station. Housed in the historic Union Station building, this place blends serious history with comfort.

What I loved: The grandeur of the rotunda, the taps behind the bar serving local ales, the menu that’s thoughtful but accessible (burgers, salads, entrees).

Pro tip: If you’re into craft beer, ask for the sampler flight of local brews. Bonus: get there early if you want a spot by the windows in the rotunda—it fills quickly.

6. College-town bar and dining spot: The Plymouth Tavern

Last but not least: The Plymouth Tavern, a downtown Erie institution that leans college-bar but serves real food, too. Since 1973, people have gathered here for burgers, drinks, and good times.

​​Honestly, it hasn’t changed much since my own college days—just the faces around the tables. I still remember grabbing dinner here during that beloved wing night, stretching a student budget while soaking in the hum of jukebox tunes and clinking glasses. 

What I loved: The brick-building charm, the buzz of students mixed with locals, the comfort of a bar with solid food—not just wings and sliders—though there are plenty of those.

Pro tip: If you visit later in the evening, expect energy. Great for post-event drinks. For quieter dining, aim for earlier in the evening.

7. Making the most of your Erie dining tour

• Book ahead: For Two45 and Brewerie, especially, reservations are super helpful.
  
• Dress for the moment: Waterfront dining calls for smart casual; college bar better fits jeans and relaxed shirts.
  
• Check for happy hour or specials: Many of these places offer weekday deals or early-evening menus.
  
• Ask about local ingredients: Lake Erie walleye, local craft beer, fresh regional sides—these details set these spots apart.
  
• Time your visit: For waterfront views, go around sunset; for quieter times, aim for midweek or just after lunch.
  

Why Erie is a foodie surprise

So there you have it—six standout restaurants in Erie, PA that cover every mood: elegant waterfront views, wood-fired steakhouse comfort, breezy patio vibes, nautical fun, historic brew-pub charm, and that irresistible college-town energy. Whether you’re visiting for a weekend, staying a couple nights, or simply passing through, you’ll leave satisfied—and probably already planning your next bite.

Erie isn’t just a lakefront destination; it’s a foodie surprise waiting to happen. Let the flavors lead your adventure.

Before you go, make sure to check out the guide, 10 Pennsylvania Getaways: Discoveries Across the Keystone State, for even more travel inspiration beyond Erie.

Call to Action: Pick two of these restaurants for your next Great Lake visit and turn it into your own mini food tour. Snap photos, note the standout dishes, and share the delicious details with your friends.

Stay curious, stay hungry, and keep exploring!

-Beth